Pirate's Cove (formerly "Andrews On The Bay"), located on a hillside in peaceful Honey Creek Bay on Lake Shafer, is a quiet family resort near Indiana Beach. Our cottages, suites, and hotel rooms are spread out on three different ground levels.  We're far enough from the hustle and bustle to relax, yet only a short walk or ferry ride from Indiana Beach.  We pride ourselves in having quality accommodations with enough amenities to make everyone feel at home.  There is a heated pool and spa with plenty of deck space for laying out.  Or you can take advantage of our fishing & boat piers.  Guests often fish off the pier where they can also  tie up their own boats. 

For the adventurous, non-stop action can be found nearby Pirate's Cove.  Spend all morning on the water, then dock your boat at one of our private docks and spend the afternoon at Indiana Beach or the golf course.